Frank, their is no cookie cut method for trolling Tony's rods and spoons. I have had fish hit them when we were going down wind and we were close to 4.5 knots and then again using his trick of dropping it to the bottom and then coming back up to the troll.
Trust me if you see that tip with a pulse, its moving. If you want try this trick, which we have done to see the difference in his spoons, have someone up on the bow drop it back and you can see the difference in the #4 to the #2. AND please use wire, their are very few spoons that work with braid correctly, some captains get lucky.
Good luck and hope this helped you a little, dont put a lot of thought into it, you will pull your hair out, just try different things and keep an accurate log.
_________________________
Capt Mark Whitney
30' Pursuit Offshore
www.erinelizabethcharters.com732-600-0596
Member:RFA
Member:Bay Head Shores Fishing Club
Member: Greater Point Pleasant Charter Boat Assoc.
Member:National Assoc. of Charterboat Operators
Pro Staff: Tony Maja tackle